“I knew her.”
“That doesn’t answer the question.”
“No,” I said. “It doesn’t.”
She studied my face. “Is Elena your daughter?”
The question was simple. The answer wasn’t.
“I don’t know.”
Hannah took a breath. “Then why did you look at her like you did?”
“Because she has a scar beneath her eye.”
“Lots of people have scars.”
“This one belonged to Sofia.”
Her expression changed. “The girl’s mother?”
I nodded.
For the first time since we met, Hannah seemed unsure what to say.
“I may be wrong,” I continued. “I may be seeing what I want to see because I’ve spent seventeen years carrying a story I never finished.”
“What story?”
“That Sofia left because she stopped loving me.”
Hannah’s voice softened. “Do you believe that?”
“I believed it because the alternative was worse.”
“What was the alternative?”
“That she left because she loved me enough to think I couldn’t change.”
The words sounded strange outside my head.
Hannah sat in the chair beside mine. “And did you?”
“Change?”
“Yes.”
I looked at the snow beyond the glass.
“I became more successful. More careful. More feared.” I gave a humorless smile. “People mistake those things for change.”
“What do you think real change would have looked like?”
“Leaving my father’s business.”
“Did you?”
“Eventually.”
“But you stayed in the same world.”
“I tried to make it less cruel.”
“That isn’t the same as leaving.”
“No.”
Her honesty should have annoyed me. Instead, it made something inside me loosen.
“My father died six years ago,” I said. “Enzo and I took over what was left. We moved the legitimate operations forward, closed the worst of the old arrangements, and walked away from the people who wanted Chicago to remain what it was.”
“Yet you still have security.”
“I have enemies.”
“Do you?”
I looked at her.
She shrugged. “You said they were asking about Elena. Maybe they are. Maybe you are simply used to seeing enemies everywhere.”
The thought had occurred to me. I didn’t want it to be true.
Before I could answer, Marco approached with a grim expression.
“Clara is on her way to the apartment,” he said. “She’ll be there in fifteen minutes.”
“Anything else?”
“The police found Elena’s phone in the wreckage. It was damaged, but they recovered the last outgoing message.”
“To whom?”
“Sofia.”
My heart stumbled.
“What did it say?”
Marco looked at his phone. “I’m sorry. I found the envelope.”
I stared at him.
“What envelope?”
“That’s all the message contained. Sent at 11:06 this morning.”
I rose again, more slowly this time.
“Did the police see it?”
“Yes.”
“What did they think?”
“They’re treating it as personal.”
“Why?”
“Because Elena had no known criminal connection, and the message was sent to a number registered to Sofia Bennett.”
My mind returned to the operating room.
The girl had been driving somewhere. She had sent her mother a message about an envelope. Then she crashed on I-290, and within minutes, strangers appeared at the hospital asking who she was.
“What was in the envelope?” I asked.
“The police haven’t found one.”
“Then why would she say she found it?”
Marco’s phone rang before he could answer.
He listened.
His face changed.
“What?” I asked when he hung up.
“Clara is at the apartment.”
“And?”
“She says the place is empty.”
A chill moved through me.
“Sofia isn’t there?”
“No. But Clara found something.”
“What?”
“She found a photograph.”
He hesitated.
“Of who?”
“Of you.”
The hallway seemed to lose its sound.
Marco continued, “It’s old. You and Sofia, standing near the lake. On the back, there’s a date.”
I could barely breathe.
“What date?”
“June 18, 2009.”
The year Elena was born.
I turned away from the hospital doors and pressed my fingers against my forehead.
A memory came back—not clearly, but in fragments.
A summer evening near Montrose Harbor. Sofia wearing a yellow dress. Her head against my shoulder. Her hand resting over her stomach.
I had asked what she was hiding.
She had smiled and said, “Nothing you need to worry about.”
Three weeks later, she disappeared.
I had always believed the photograph was taken before the end, before she decided to leave.
But the date changed everything.
“Send me a copy,” I said.
Marco did.
The image appeared on his screen first, then on mine.
Sofia stood beside me beneath a wide blue sky, her hair blowing across her cheek. I was younger, less guarded, looking at her instead of the camera.
She was smiling.
Not the careful smile she had worn when she was afraid.
A real one.
Her left hand rested lightly over her abdomen.
I stared at it.
Hannah saw the photograph over my shoulder. Her expression shifted as understanding arrived.
“How far along?” she asked quietly.
I couldn’t answer.
Marco enlarged the image. On the back, beneath the date, someone had written a sentence in faded black ink.
_I wanted you to know before I was gone._
My chest tightened.
“What does that mean?” Hannah asked.
“I don’t know.”
But I did.
Or part of me did.
Sofia had been pregnant.
She had known.
And she had planned to tell me.
Something must have happened before she could.
“Mr. Mancini?” Dr. Patel called from the operating-room doors.
I turned.
He had changed his gloves and looked more serious than before.
“She’s stable enough to move to intensive care,” he said. “You may see her briefly once we settle her.”
“Thank you.”
He nodded. “There is one other matter. The police found a note in the vehicle. It wasn’t addressed, but it may have been intended for her mother.”
“Can I see it?”
“Only if the police approve. They’re on their way.”
“What does it say?”
Dr. Patel glanced down at the folder in his hands.
“Something about a man named Luca.”
For several seconds, no one spoke.
The noise of the hospital returned in pieces—the wheels of a cart, the distant ring of a telephone, the quiet murmur of someone praying near the elevators.
Hannah looked at me.
Marco’s hand moved toward his jacket, though there was nothing he could do to prepare for words already written.
Dr. Patel opened the folder and read from the note.
“Mom, if anything happens to me, find Luca Mancini. He deserves to know that you lied to him.”
My knees weakened.
Hannah caught my arm again.
Dr. Patel continued, unaware that the words had already torn open seventeen years of silence.
“She wrote one more line.”
He looked directly at me.
“She said, ‘He is my father.’”
See more on the next page